By Doug Young

Key Takeaways

  • The Great American Coin Company offers a wide array of coins and collectibles, including rare and specialty items.
  • With a history of over two decades, they’ve built a reputation for being a trusted supplier in the numismatic community.
  • Customer service is a priority, with knowledgeable staff ready to assist both novice and experienced collectors.
  • Authenticity is guaranteed through industry affiliations and partnerships with grading services.
  • Understanding coin grading and historical value can significantly enhance your collecting experience and potential investment returns.

A Heads Up before getting deep into this review:

Having evaluated a great number of Gold IRA providers over the past decade or so I am well positioned and committed to providing you with comprehensive and informative content to empower your decision-making process.
I've meticulously compiled a list of the top gold IRA investing companies, so you can easily compare and select the one that perfectly aligns with your needs. My in-depth research and analysis ensure that you have all the knowledge necessary to make an informed choice.
Explore my handpicked selection of the very best Gold IRA Companies of by clicking here.
Or save time and go straight to my review of Augusta Precious Metals, the gold IRA provider that I confidently recommend as the market leader in .

A Closer Look at Great American Coin Company

Great American Coin Company analysis
When you’re delving into the world of numismatics, the Great American Coin Company stands out as a beacon for collectors. Whether you’re starting your journey into coin collecting or you’re an experienced numismatist, you’ll find that their offerings cover the full spectrum of interests, from precious metals to rare numismatic treasures.

The Intrigue of Collecting

Collecting coins is more than just a hobby; it’s a window into history, an investment, and a challenge. Coins tell stories of empires, economies, and epochs. They are tangible pieces of history you can hold in your hand. But remember, it’s not just about the coin’s face value; it’s the scarcity, condition, and historical significance that often create the true value.

Most importantly, the joy of collecting comes from the thrill of the hunt. Finding that one elusive coin can be incredibly rewarding. It’s about piecing together a puzzle that spans centuries and continents. And that’s where a reliable coin dealer comes into play.

Brief Company History

The Great American Coin Company, with roots planted firmly in Los Angeles since 2006, is not just a business; it’s a passion project. Founded by Gary Dyner, the company has grown from a small family-owned operation to a well-respected entity in the coin collecting community. Their commitment to integrity and customer satisfaction is what has kept them in business for over two decades.

Catalogue Overview

One glance at their catalogue and you’ll be taken aback by the variety. They have everything from freshly minted bullion to coins that have seen the rise and fall of civilizations. But it’s not just about variety; it’s about quality and authenticity. Each coin tells a story, and Great American Coin Company ensures that story is genuine and well-preserved.

Popular Coin Collections

Let’s dive into some of the popular collections you might explore with Great American Coin Company:

  • U.S. Coins: From the latest state quarters to century-old Indian Head pennies, there’s something for every patriot and history buff.
  • World Coins: Expand your collection’s horizon with coins from around the globe, each with its unique design and backstory.
  • Silver and Gold Bullion: For those who view collecting as an investment, bullion coins offer the intrinsic value of precious metals with the added bonus of collectability.

Rare Finds and Specialty Items

But what about the rare gems? The coins that make collectors’ hearts skip a beat? Great American Coin Company has those too. They offer ancient coins that have traversed time, like Roman denarii or Greek drachmas. Then there are the error coins, minted with a flaw that makes them unique and often more valuable.

Customer Experience

When it comes to collecting, the experience should be as rewarding as the treasures you acquire. Great American Coin Company understands this and has tailored their customer service to ensure that every interaction is positive. They have knowledgeable staff who are not just salespeople but fellow enthusiasts, ready to guide you through your collecting journey.

Service and Support

If you’re new to the game or have a question about a specific piece, the support team at Great American Coin Company is there to assist. They can provide insights into the historical context of a piece, offer advice on care and storage, or help you navigate the sometimes complex world of coin grading. This level of service ensures that every collector, regardless of experience, feels valued and informed.

Client Testimonials

But don’t just take my word for it. Client testimonials speak volumes about the company’s reputation. Customers rave about the quality of the coins, the ease of transactions, and the exceptional customer service. These stories of satisfaction are a testament to the company’s dedication to their clients.

Trust and Credibility

Trust is the cornerstone of any collector-dealer relationship. You want to know that the coins you’re buying are authentic, fairly priced, and sold with transparent policies. Great American Coin Company has built their credibility on these principles, ensuring collectors can make purchases with confidence.

“I’ve been collecting coins for over a decade, and Great American Coin Company has never let me down. Their coins are authentic, and they have some of the best customer service I’ve come across in the industry.” – Jordan M., an avid coin collector

Authenticity Verification

Great American Coin Company takes authenticity seriously. They understand that a coin’s value is intrinsically linked to its authenticity. As a result, they have strict verification processes in place and provide detailed information about the origin and history of their coins. This commitment to authenticity helps protect your investment and ensures the legacy of your collection.

Industry Affiliations and Partnerships

Besides their internal expertise, Great American Coin Company is affiliated with reputable organizations like the American Numismatic Association and is an authorized dealer for major grading services. These affiliations offer an extra layer of trust and authenticity to their products and services.

The Hunt for History: Enhancing the Collection

Enhancing the Collection

Every coin has a story, and adding historical coins to your collection is like owning a piece of that story. Great American Coin Company offers a selection of coins that are not just currency but artifacts of bygone eras, providing a tangible connection to the past.

Consider the thrill of holding a coin from the Roman Empire or the early days of the American Republic. These coins are not just metal; they’re milestones of human civilization. Collecting them is a way to preserve and honor history.

Historical Significance of Coins

Understanding the historical significance of coins can greatly enhance your appreciation of them. For example, a Morgan silver dollar isn’t just a piece of silver; it represents the ingenuity and expansion of the United States in the late 19th century. This context adds depth to your collection and can make the experience much more fulfilling.

Adding Value to Your Collection

Furthermore, the historical importance of a coin can add to its monetary value. Coins that played a significant role in history or are from a pivotal moment tend to appreciate in value over time. Therefore, when choosing coins for your collection, consider their stories and the potential for future value appreciation.

Treasure or Trifle: Making the Right Purchase

So, how do you determine if a coin is a treasure worth pursuing or a trifle to pass up? It comes down to research, understanding the market, and sometimes, trusting your gut. Knowing the history, rarity, and condition of a coin will guide you in making wise purchases.

Identifying High-Potential Coins

Here are some steps to help you identify coins with high potential:

  • Research the coin’s history: Who minted it, and when? What was happening in the world at that time?
  • Understand rarity: How many of these coins were minted, and how many are believed to still exist?
  • Examine condition: Is the coin well-preserved, or does it show signs of significant wear and tear?
  • Check for authenticity: Ensure the coin has been verified by a reputable source.

By following these steps, you can make informed decisions and grow a collection that is not only personally satisfying but potentially profitable as well.

Understanding Coin Grading

Coin grading is an essential aspect of numismatics. It’s the process of determining the condition of a coin, which directly affects its value. Think of it like grading a diamond. A flawless diamond is worth more than one with imperfections. The same goes for coins. A coin in ‘mint’ condition, which means it looks as if it just came off the press, could be worth a lot more than one that’s been heavily circulated.

Grading can be complex, but here’s the gist: coins are graded on a scale from 1 to 70, with 70 being perfect. Professional grading companies like PCGS and NGC use this scale to provide an objective assessment of a coin’s condition. As a collector, understanding this grading system can help you make better purchasing decisions and understand the value of your collection.



Now, let’s answer some frequently asked questions that might be on your mind about the Great American Coin Company.

What types of coins can I find at Great American Coin Company?

At Great American Coin Company, you’ll find a wide range of coins, including:

  • U.S. coins, from historic pieces like Morgan silver dollars to modern commemorative coins.
  • World coins from various countries and eras, offering a glimpse into different cultures and histories.
  • Bullion coins made from precious metals like gold, silver, and platinum, which are popular among investors.
  • Rare and ancient coins, for those looking for a piece of history or a unique addition to their collection.
  • Error coins, which are mint mistakes that often carry unique value due to their rarity.

How does the Great American Coin Company ensure the authenticity of their coins?

The company takes several steps to guarantee the authenticity of their coins:

  • Each coin is examined by their team of experts to confirm its authenticity before it’s offered for sale.
  • They use industry-standard guidelines for grading and authentication, ensuring consistency and reliability.
  • Great American Coin Company is affiliated with respected organizations and grading services, which further attests to their commitment to authenticity.

What is the purchasing process like for new collectors?

For new collectors, the purchasing process is straightforward:

  • Browse the online catalog to find coins that interest you.
  • Read the descriptions carefully to understand the history and condition of the coin.
  • If you have questions, reach out to their customer service for guidance.
  • Once you’ve made your selection, you can purchase directly through the website or by contacting the company.

Great American Coin Company makes it easy and stress-free for new collectors to start their journey.

Does Great American Coin Company offer investment advice?

While Great American Coin Company has a wealth of knowledge about numismatics, they do not offer direct investment advice. They provide collectors with the information and resources to understand the value and potential of their coins, but decisions about investing should be made with the guidance of a financial advisor.

What should I do if I have a rare coin I want to evaluate or sell?

If you have a rare coin, here’s what you can do:

  • Contact Great American Coin Company to express your interest in selling or having your coin evaluated.
  • Provide clear images and as much information as possible about the coin’s history and condition.
  • Their experts will assess your coin and offer you a valuation based on current market trends and the coin’s rarity and condition.
  • If you decide to sell, they can guide you through the process to ensure a smooth transaction.

Remember, transparency and communication are key when dealing with rare coins.


I recommend that before you commit to any Gold IRA provider you check out why the Company that I confidently endorse as the industry leader in stands out from the rest.


I recommend that before you commit to any Gold IRA provider you check out why the Company that I confidently endorse as the industry leader in stands out from the rest.

About the Author: Doug Young
Doug YoungDoug is a highly experienced professional and widely trusted authority in financial investing, commodity trading, and precious metals. With over 20 years of expertise, he helps others make informed decisions by sharing a combination of personal experience, extensive knowledge and meticulously researched information on gold IRAs, precious metals investing and retirement planning. He regularly writes news items on these topics. He has considerable experience of evaluating Gold IRA and Precious Metals Companies, gained over a period spanning more than a decade.

See full bio