Bond Yields Hit 5% as Fed Debt Denial Backfires

By Doug Young – 31 May 2025

The Fed’s Defiant Stance Meets Market Reality

May FOMC Meeting: Optimism Amid Storm Clouds

In its May 2025 meeting, the Federal Reserve maintained the federal funds rate at a range of 4.25% to 4.50%, signaling a pause amid mixed economic signals.

Official statements emphasized that economic activity was expanding at a solid pace and the labor market remained strong, supporting the Fed’s decision to hold rates steady. Inflation was described as moderating but still above target, justifying a cautious “wait and see” approach.

Yet, beneath this official optimism, the Fed’s meeting minutes revealed growing concerns about market volatility and liquidity stresses, particularly in Treasury markets.

Despite these acknowledgments, the Fed continued to assert that economic fundamentals were sound, creating a disconnect between internal unease and public messaging.

This divergence has fueled skepticism among investors, who are increasingly pricing in risks that the Fed appears to downplay

Powell’s Political Tightrope

Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell has resisted political pressure to cut rates prematurely, notably rejecting calls from President Trump to ease monetary policy despite signs of economic slowdown.

Powell’s insistence on data-dependent policy has kept rates elevated, but the bond market tells a different story, with yields climbing sharply as investors price in heightened risk and uncertainty.

This tension highlights the Fed’s difficult balancing act: maintaining credibility in fighting inflation while avoiding actions that could destabilize the government’s massive debt burden.

The Fed’s public stance of economic resilience increasingly contrasts with market signals that suggest deeper structural problems.

Anatomy of a Yield Spike: From 4.5% to 5%

Treasury Market Mechanics Breaking Down

The U.S. Treasury yield curve has experienced a dramatic shift, with the 10-year yield hovering around 4.5% and the 30-year yield recently touching and briefly exceeding 5%, levels not seen in over a decade.

Traditionally, Treasury bonds serve as safe-haven assets, rising when stocks fall. However, recent market behavior has defied this norm: Treasuries have fallen alongside equities and the U.S. dollar, signaling a loss of confidence in government debt as a refuge.

Liquidity in Treasury markets has deteriorated following Fed policy announcements, exacerbating price swings and contributing to the yield surge.

This breakdown in normal market dynamics indicates that investors are reassessing the risk profile of U.S. debt, reflecting concerns about fiscal sustainability and monetary policy constraints.

The $36 Trillion Anchor

The U.S. national debt has surpassed $35.9 trillion, growing at an unprecedented pace of roughly $1 trillion every 100 days.

This staggering figure is held by a diverse group of creditors: the Federal Reserve owns approximately $4.7 trillion, foreign investors hold $8.7 trillion, and domestic investors account for $19.7 trillion

Japan, as one of the largest foreign holders with $1.13 trillion in Treasuries, represents a potential trigger point for further market disruption.

Any significant liquidation of Japanese Treasury holdings could send yields soaring higher, intensifying the debt servicing burden on the U.S. government and amplifying market volatility

Global Investors Rewrite the Playbook

The Great Dollar Diversification

Major global investors are actively reducing their exposure to U.S. dollar assets.

Financial giants such as JPMorgan and Goldman Sachs report that clients are seeking to diversify into eurozone, Japanese, and Australian bonds, reflecting waning confidence in the dollar’s stability.

China has notably decreased its Treasury holdings by approximately $200 billion since 2022, while BRICS nations are pushing for alternatives to dollar dominance through new currency arrangements.

This shift signals a structural realignment in global capital flows, undermining the dollar’s traditional role as the world’s reserve currency and challenging the U.S. Treasury’s ability to finance its debt at favorable rates.

Japan’s Unspoken Leverage

Japan’s domestic bond market is under strain, with auction failures and rising yields raising concerns about its sovereign debt sustainability.

Japanese investors have historically engaged in yen carry trades, borrowing cheaply in yen to invest in higher-yielding U.S. Treasuries.

JPMorgan warns that the unwinding of these trades is only halfway complete, implying that Japan may need to sell a significant portion of its Treasury holdings—potentially up to 10%, or $113 billion—which could trigger a sharp spike in U.S. yields.

This scenario echoes the 2013 “taper tantrum“, when fears of Fed tightening led to a sudden surge in Treasury yields and mortgage rates, disrupting markets worldwide.

A similar episode today would exacerbate the Fed’s policy challenges and raise borrowing costs across the U.S. economy.

Credit Markets Sound the Alarm

CDS Market: Pricing In the Unthinkable

Credit default swaps (CDS) on U.S. government debt have surged dramatically, with the cost of insuring $10 million of Treasury securities rising from $29,000 to over $51,000 annually.

This spike reflects growing market concern about the possibility of U.S. sovereign default—a scenario once considered nearly impossible.

The rise in CDS prices signals that sophisticated investors are actively hedging against credit risk, undermining the long-held assumption that U.S. debt is risk-free collateral.

This shift could have wide-reaching implications for global financial stability.

Corporate Debt Domino Effect

The stress in sovereign debt markets is spilling over into corporate credit.

Junk bond spreads have widened to over 600 basis points above Treasuries, indicating heightened default risk among lower-rated borrowers.

The Fed’s constrained balance sheet limits its ability to act as a backstop, leaving markets vulnerable to a cascade of credit downgrades and defaults

This credit market turbulence threatens to tighten financial conditions further, potentially slowing economic growth and complicating the Fed’s policy decisions.

The Fed’s No-Win Calculus

Rate Hike Paralysis

The Federal Reserve faces a policy trap: raising interest rates to combat inflation would increase the government’s debt servicing costs by hundreds of billions annually, risking a fiscal crisis.

For example, a 1% hike in rates could add more than $350 billion to annual interest payments, crowding out other spending priorities and fueling political backlash.

Conversely, cutting rates to stimulate growth risks reigniting inflation and further weakening the dollar’s international standing.

This dilemma leaves the Fed effectively paralyzed, unable to adjust policy without triggering serious economic or fiscal consequences.

Inflation/Deflation Trap

Inflation remains sticky, partly due to tariffs and supply chain disruptions, complicating the Fed’s efforts to bring prices under control.

Meanwhile, the potential for a Treasury liquidation spiral threatens deflationary pressures through collapsing bond prices and tightening credit conditions.

This inflation-deflation tug-of-war constrains policy options and heightens the risk of stagflation or a debt-driven market crisis, making the Fed’s job increasingly precarious.

Conclusion: Denial’s Expiration Date

The Federal Reserve’s narrative of economic strength and policy effectiveness is increasingly at odds with market realities.

Bond yields breaching 5%, surging default insurance costs, the gold rally and global diversification away from the dollar all point to a growing crisis of confidence in U.S. fiscal management.

There is mounting evidence suggesting that sophisticated investors are already positioning for potential monetary system instability, regardless of official Federal Reserve positive declarations.

History shows that loss of monetary policy credibility can lead to severe economic dislocations, as seen during the stagflation era of the 1970s.

Without decisive action to address the structural debt and monetary challenges, the U.S. risks a protracted period of financial instability.

As markets price in these risks, the Fed’s denial may soon reach its expiration date, forcing a reckoning with the unsustainable trajectory of debt and monetary policy that now threatens the foundation of the American economy.

Discover Why Savvy Retirees are Diversifying With Gold