By Doug Young

Silver vs Gold Performance Comparison Over Time

Key Takeaways

  • Gold is often more stable than silver due to its limited supply and safe-haven status.
  • Silver’s price is more volatile because of its industrial demand and smaller market size.
  • The gold-silver ratio helps investors understand their relative value and historical price trends.
  • Economic uncertainty and inflation can cause silver to outperform gold at times.
  • Both metals are influenced by global events, supply-demand dynamics, and investor sentiment.

Annual Silver vs Gold Performance from 2000 to 2024

Year Gold Average Price (USD) Silver Average Price (USD) Gold Annual % Change Silver Annual % Change
2000 $279.29 $4.95
2001 $271.19 $4.37 -2.81% -11.73%
2002 $310.08 $4.60 14.31% 5.26%
2003 $363.83 $4.89 17.30% 6.30%
2004 $409.53 $6.66 12.63% 36.25%
2005 $444.99 $7.31 8.61% 9.77%
2006 $604.34 $11.55 35.88% 58.94%
2007 $696.43 $13.38 15.19% 15.83%
2008 $872.37 $14.99 25.45% 12.04%
2009 $1,212.50 $14.67 11.46% -2.14%
2010 $1,421.00 $20.19 25.92% 37.16%
2011 $1,895.00 $35.12 28.49% 73.57%
2012 $1,791.75 $31.15 -5.47% -11.29%
2013 $1,693.75 $23.79 -5.44% -23.63%
2014 $1,385.00 $19.08 -18.18% -19.86%
2015 $1,160.06 $15.68 -16.06% -17.05%
2016 $1,251.92 $17.14 7.89% 9.28%
2017 $1,260.39 $17.05 0.37% -0.52%
2018 $1,268.93 $15.71 0.26% -10.44%
2019 $1,546.10 $16.21 21.85% -9.52%
2020 $1,773..73 $20..55 14..71% 26..49%
2021 $1,798..89 $24..38 1..57% 18..52%
2022 $1,801.87 $21.09 0.17% -13.06%
2023 $1,943.00 $23.50 7.87% 11.44%
2024 $2,388.98 $29.80 22.93% 26.53%

Average Changes Over the Period (2000-2024)

  • Average Gold Annual % Change: ~8%
  • Average Silver Annual % Change: ~7%

Key Differences in Volatility and Stability

One of the most important differences between gold and silver is their volatility.

Silver’s price can fluctuate more dramatically than gold’s. This is partly due to its smaller market size and the significant industrial demand for silver in electronics, solar panels, and other applications.

Gold is a popular choice during economic downturns or when inflation is high. It’s perceived as a safe bet and more stable investment. It tends to maintain its value better over long periods, which is why it’s favored by conservative investors seeking to preserve wealth.

Nonetheless, during periods of high economic uncertainty or inflation, silver can sometimes outperform gold. This is because its industrial demand can drive up prices quickly, providing opportunities for higher returns in a shorter period, albeit with higher risk.

Silver vs Gold Performance and Volatility Over Time

The following two graphs give a good visual comparison of the performances and volatilities over time of silver and gold:

Silver’s Performance and Volatility Since 1975

silver's performance since 1975

Gold’s Performance and Volatility Since 1975

gold's performance since 1975

Historical Long-Term Price Trendsgold vs silver price trends

Gold Performance Over the Decades

Gold has generally shown a steady increase in value over the decades. Its performance is often tied to global economic conditions, inflation rates, and geopolitical events. Investors have historically turned to gold as a hedge against inflation and currency devaluation.

Silver Price Fluctuations Through Time

Silver’s price has been more volatile than gold’s, with significant fluctuations over time. This volatility can be attributed to its dual role as both a precious and industrial metal. The demand for silver in industrial applications can cause rapid price changes, especially during economic booms or downturns.

For example, during the 1980s, silver prices spiked dramatically due to increased industrial demand and speculative trading. However, these prices later stabilized, reflecting the metal’s inherent volatility.

External Factors Influencing Prices

Several external factors influence the prices of gold and silver. These include economic indicators, political events, and global market trends. During times of economic uncertainty, both metals often see increased demand as investors seek safe-haven assets.

Changes in industrial demand, particularly for silver, can have a big impact on prices. As technology advances and new applications for silver are developed, its demand and price can fluctuate accordingly.

Supply and Demand Dynamics

The supply and demand dynamics of gold and silver play a crucial role in determining their prices. Gold’s supply is relatively stable, with most of it coming from mining and recycling. The demand for gold is driven by jewelry, investment, and central bank purchases. This consistent demand helps maintain its price stability.

Silver, however, has a more complex supply-demand equation. It is not only used for investment and jewelry but also has significant industrial applications. This industrial demand can cause substantial price fluctuations. For example, when the demand for electronics or solar panels increases, the demand for silver rises, potentially driving up its price.

Role of Economic Indicators

Economic indicators such as inflation rates, interest rates, and currency strength can significantly influence the prices of gold and silver. During periods of high inflation, investors often turn to gold as a hedge, driving up its price. Conversely, when interest rates go up, the opportunity cost of holding non-yielding assets such as gold rises, and this can lead to a decrease in its demand and price.

Silver is also affected by these indicators but to a lesser extent. Its price is more sensitive to changes in industrial demand. However, in times of economic uncertainty, both metals can see increased demand as investors seek to protect their wealth.

Political and Global Events Impact

Political and global events can have a profound impact on the prices of gold and silver. Geopolitical tensions, wars, and economic crises often lead to increased demand for these metals as safe-haven assets. As an example, during the financial crisis of 2008, gold prices surged as investors sought stability amidst the market turmoil.

Similarly, silver can experience price increases during such events, although its industrial demand can sometimes counteract these effects. The interplay between silver’s industrial and investment demand makes its price more volatile in response to global events.

Gold-Silver Ratio

The gold-silver ratio (how many ounces of silver are needed to buy one ounce of gold) is a key indicator of the relative value of the two metals.

A high ratio suggests that silver is undervalued compared to gold, potentially signaling a buying opportunity for silver. Conversely, a low ratio may indicate that gold is undervalued. Investors can use this ratio to inform their investment strategies and timing.

The gold-silver ratio has averaged around 65:1 since the 1970s.

Average Gold-Silver Ratio from 2000 to 2024

The following table presents the annual gold-silver ratio from 2000 to the end of 2024, indicating how many ounces of silver are equivalent in value to one ounce of gold for each year. The average ratio calculated at the bottom provides insight into the long-term relationship between these two precious metals over the specified period.

Year Gold-Silver Ratio
2000 56.3
2001 62.1
2002 67.3
2003 74.3
2004 61.5
2005 60.9
2006 52.3
2007 51.9
2008 58.1
2009 82.5
2010 70.3
2011 50.5
2012 57.5
2013 59.1
2014 72.6
2015 73.7
2016 73.0
2017 73.9
2018 85.2
2019 95.4
2020 105.0
2021 74.0
2022 85.5
2023 82.6
2024 80.6
Average: 71.9

This table shows that since 2022 the gold-silver ratio has remained above 80:1. When comparing that with the average of 65:1 since the 1970s the divergence suggests that silver is currently undervalued.

Future Outlook

Predictions for Gold

Looking ahead, gold is expected to remain a valuable investment asset. Its price will likely continue to be influenced by economic indicators, central bank policies, and geopolitical events. As inflation concerns persist, gold may see increased demand as a hedge against currency devaluation.

The Reasons Why Top Analysts Are Bullish About The Prospects for Gold in 2025

LEARN MORE! SIGN UP FOR YOUR FREE WEB CONFERENCE

Expectations for Silver

Silver’s future performance will largely depend on its industrial demand. As technology advances and the demand for electronics and renewable energy sources grows, silver could see increased demand and higher prices.

Stunning New Tech Development Could Have a Significant Impact on the Price of Silver

LEARN MORE! SIGN UP FOR YOUR FREE WEB CONFERENCE >>

Why Experts Predict a 20% Surge for Silver in 2025

LEARN MORE! SIGN UP FOR YOUR FREE WEB CONFERENCE

Discover

About the Author: Doug Young
Doug YoungDoug is a highly experienced professional and widely trusted authority in financial investing, commodity trading, and precious metals. With over 20 years of expertise, he helps others make informed decisions by sharing a combination of personal experience, extensive knowledge and meticulously researched information on gold IRAs, precious metals investing and retirement planning. He regularly writes news items on these topics. He has considerable experience of evaluating Gold IRA and Precious Metals Companies, gained over a period spanning more than a decade.

See full bio